Launch period: all checks are free
OpenPlag Labs
A glam-style illustration: a silhouetted figure against a starry night sky, a document with highlighted passages, a guitar, books, a disco ball and a typewriter

Starman and the scissors

Before we start, put your favourite David Bowie song on in the background. If you can't choose, "Starman" is a fine place to begin. This week's post was written for it.

In the seventies Bowie wrote some of his songs with scissors. He cut sentences out of newspapers and diaries, shuffled the strips and looked in the new combinations for something he would not have thought of on his own. He did not invent the method. He learned it from William Burroughs.

And Burroughs did not invent it either. In October 1959, in a shabby Paris hotel later known as the Beat Hotel, the painter Brion Gysin sliced with a knife through a pile of newspapers he was using as a work surface. Looking at the cut strips, he found new sentences in them. Burroughs was so excited that when he wrote about the method, he called his essay "The Cut-Up Method of Brion Gysin". For the rest of his life he kept telling people the idea was not his. And to be even more precise, Gysin had a predecessor too: in the 1920s the poet Tristan Tzara proposed writing a poem by pulling words out of a hat.

In other words, a technique built entirely on chance came with a remarkably tidy chain of attribution. Everyone who used it knew where it came from, and said so.

In 1995 Bowie took it a step further. With the programmer Ty Roberts he built a program called the Verbasizer, which did what the scissors had done: it took sentences, cut them up and assembled new combinations. He used it to write the lyrics for the album Outside. And when he showed it on camera, he made a point of saying he had developed it with a friend.

Nobody claimed the program wrote the songs. It offered combinations, and Bowie chose. He threw away most of what it offered, kept a little, and reworked what he kept. Responsibility for every line that went out into the world was his.

Today every researcher sits in front of a far more sophisticated Verbasizer. AI suggests connections, phrasings, and sometimes a real idea that would not have occurred to us. And then the questions come: Is it allowed to use this? Do we need to cite it? Is that even possible?

Allowed? Yes. A tool is not an author, and not a source of authority either. You cannot write "so said the machine" and move on. But when a tool helped us reach an idea, basic fairness requires saying so, just as Burroughs named Gysin.

Possible? Partly. The style guides already know how to cite the tool or the conversation. What is missing is a way to cite what really matters: a finding. An idea that came up while working with a machine, and that the researcher then checked and verified.

That is why we have published a proposal for discussion called Type-Specimen Citation. The name comes from zoology: a new species gets a name only when one specimen is deposited in a collection, with a catalogue number, so that anyone can come and check. In the same way, a finding reached with the help of AI is marked in the text, entered in a separate list, and linked to a table of the sources that verify it. A finding without verification counts as a missing citation.

In another Bowie song, an astronaut loses contact with ground control and drifts off into space. That is exactly what happens to an idea that was never checked. It may sparkle, but it has nowhere to come back to. The verification table is our ground control.

The proposal is still a draft, and it will only be as good as the discussion around it. Close to five hundred people have already read it, and some have already tried it on their own work. If you have a question, an objection, or a case the method cannot handle, we want to hear it. Join the discussion on Academia. And if you would like to start from the basics, our guide to the common citation styles is here on the site.

Want to see this on your own paper? Run a check. Free during the launch period.

Sign up Guides

Get the blog by e-mail

One new post a week, straight to your inbox. No spam, and you can leave with one click.

We will send you a confirmation e-mail. Your address is used only to send the blog. Privacy policy

More from the blog